Controversial creative accounting and its impact on companies

Controversial creative accounting and its impact on companies

Learn about creative accounting, its risks and benefits and how to avoid this controversial practice. Understand why ethics in accounting is fundamental to the success of companies. 

The complexity of tax obligations and the pressure for favorable financial indicators lead Brazilian companies to look for innovative solutions. In this scenario, creative accounting has emerged as a controversial practice that may seem advantageous at first glance.  

However, it is essential to understand that creative accounting does not generate sustainable benefits in the long term; on the contrary, it can lead companies to adopt fictitious results or, even worse, to commit tax crimes before the Internal Revenue Service. 

[Article]: Americanas reveals net loss of R$ 12.9 billion in 2022 balance sheet

What is cWhat's new?

Creative accounting is the practice of manipulating financial data to mask a company's true economic situation. This manipulation is carried out in order to gain advantages, such as artificially increasing profits, reducing taxes payable or improving the appearance of balance sheets to attract investors. 

Loopholes and ambiguities in tax laws are often exploited by companies that adopt creative accounting. Common practices include prematurely recognizing income, omitting liabilities, using hidden reserves, overvaluing assets and reclassifying expenses as investments.  

Although it may seem like a quick solution to immediate financial problems, data "masking" brings with it a series of risks and negative consequences. 

[Article]: How accounting errors affected Magazine Luiza's assets

Creative accounting is permitted by law.hey?

In this practice, there is a fine line between strategically combining data to gain tax advantages and tax evasion. Although accounting strategies can be used legally to minimize the tax burden, there are situations in which they go beyond the legitimate limit and become tax evasion. 

Tax evasion is considered a crime under Federal Law No. 4.729 of 1965. It can result in imprisonment from six months to two years, as well as a fine of up to five times the amount of the tax evaded. The penalties are applied to those responsible for the crime, whether they are individuals or companies. 

The Federal Revenue Service, which is responsible for tax inspection in Brazil, has control and auditing mechanisms in place to identify cases of tax evasion. If tax evasion is proven, the company will be subject to the legal consequences mentioned above, as well as possible damage to its reputation in the market. 

[Article]: Veto on payroll exemption affects more than 17 sectors in Brazil

Best practices to avoid creative accounting

To avoid manipulating financial data, it is essential to adopt the following practices. 

Accounting transparency and compliance

Adopting a clear stance on accounting practices, guaranteeing accounting compliance, is fundamental. This includes the correct classification and measurement of assets, liabilities, income and expenses, as well as meeting deadlines for filing tax returns and paying taxes. 

[Article]: Accounting firm for your company see the pros and cons

Ethics and professional responsibility

Accounting professionals must adhere to ethical principles such as honesty, impartiality and objectivity. They must act responsibly, putting the interests of the company and its stakeholders first and avoiding practices that could distort or manipulate the financial statements. 

[Article]: 7 accounting mistakes that can put your company at risk

Strengthening internal controls

Companies need a solid structure to prevent dubious or fraudulent practices, including in accounting activities. This involves defining clear responsibilities and implementing monitoring systems, such as periodic reconciliations and regular analysis of financial reports. 

[Article]: The vital significance of indicators for companies

Independent audit and third-party review

Independent auditors play an important role in reducing the risk of manipulation or distortion of accounting information. They provide an independent and reliable assessment of the company's financial operations, identifying possible errors, omissions or fraud in the financial statements. 

[Article]: The importance of strategic planning for foreign trade companies

Risks and benefits of creative accounting

Creative accounting can bring temporary benefits to companies, such as improving the appearance of financial results, reducing tax burdens and conforming to market expectations. However, these benefits are unsustainable in the long term. 

Short-term benefits of creative accounting

• Improved appearance of financial results. 
• Reducing the tax burden. 
• Damage to market reputation. 

[Article]: How accounting 4.0 works and what the challenges are

What to do if you don't need accountingWhat's new?

To avoid the manipulation of financial data, it is essential to have accountants and accounting consultants who are honest and aligned with the company's results and goals. The use of accounting software can reduce dependence on manual intervention and automate the recording, monitoring and processing of transactions, achieving a reliable and transparent accounting flow. 

Another advantage of accounting software is its ability to generate accurate and detailed financial reports. These documents help identify growth opportunities and mitigate risks for the company. 

SouthRock Capital: Billion-dollar debt and the receivership of the Starbucks and Subway brands

Think about your company's accounting future

Creative accounting may seem like a quick fix for financial problems, but the risks involved are significant. Ethical practices in accounting and financial management are fundamental to the success of companies.  

Transparency, accounting compliance and a commitment to honesty are essential to maintaining stakeholder trust and avoiding negative consequences, including legal penalties and reputational damage in the market. 

If you need to rely on experienced accounting advice, capable of providing the best strategies for your company to improve its financial performance, get to know CLM Controller's solutions now.