CLT vs. PJ: how should your company hire?
The choice between hiring an employee under the Consolidation of Labor Laws (CLT) or as a Legal Entity (PJ) is a crucial decision for companies. Both hiring models have their advantages and disadvantages, and the right choice depends on your company's specific needs, as well as current legislation. In this article, we'll explore the main differences between CLT and PJ and how your company should make this important decision.
[Article]: Find out how notice works
CLT (Consolidation of Labor Laws)
The CLT provides legal certainty for employers and employees, guaranteeing labor rights such as paid vacations and 13th salary. It also simplifies management, as the company only has to deal with deductions and the transfer of charges. However, costs can be high, and rigid labor relations can limit flexibility.
[Article]: Human resources department: Duties and importance in people management
Advantages of the CLT for your company
Legal certainty
The CLT provides a solid legal framework that protects both the employer and the employee. This includes labor rights such as paid vacation, 13th salary, FGTS (Severance Indemnity Fund) and other benefits.
[Article] Accounting mistakes that big companies make
Ease of management
The employer doesn't have to worry about managing taxes and labor charges, as the company is responsible for making the deductions and transfers that are due.
[Article]: 7 accounting mistakes that can put your company at risk
Disadvantages of the CLT for your company
High costs
Hiring an employee under the CLT regime can be more expensive for the company, due to social security charges, taxes and mandatory benefits.
[Article]: Tax reform for small and medium-sized enterprises
Rigidity in labor relations
The CLT imposes certain rules and limitations on the relationship between employee and employer, which can hinder flexibility in personnel management.
Legal entity
Hiring as a PJ can be advantageous due to lower labor charges and greater contractual flexibility. Professionals also have more autonomy. However, it is important to be aware of the constantly evolving legal risks. Therefore, the choice between CLT and PJ should consider not only costs, but also the specific needs of the project and the legal conditions in force.
[Article]: Fiscal complexity in Brazil
Advantages of PJ for your company
Less labor charges
Hiring a professional as a PJ usually results in lower labor and tax costs for the company, since the contractor is responsible for their taxes and benefits.
[Article]: Tax compliance, you must comply to grow!
Contractual flexibility
Companies have more freedom to negotiate contractual terms with PJ professionals, allowing tailor-made agreements for specific projects.
Revisions and adaptations needed in the corporate planning of an up-and-coming company
Disadvantages of PJ for your company
Risk of legal challenge
Legislation and case law can question the PJ relationship if the professional works exclusively for the company, which could lead to labor lawsuits.
[Article]: The importance of liability insurance for protecting clients
Lack of benefits
PJ professionals are not entitled to the same benefits as CLT employees, such as paid vacation and 13th salary.
[Article]: Find out how much an employee costs your company
Conclusion
Remember that each case is unique, and the choice between CLT and PJ should be based on the characteristics of the job, the preferences of the professional and the laws in force. Consulting a legal or accounting expert is always recommended to ensure that your company complies with labor and tax legislation. So make a careful assessment and make an informed decision to meet the needs of your company and your employees.
If you need to rely on experienced accounting advice, capable of providing the best strategies for your company to improve its financial performance, get to know CLM Controller's solutions now.
Upgrade your finances:
Talk to us!
